ICSA has met with the Minister for Communications, Climate Action and the Environment Mr Denis Naughten to make the case for renewable energy policies that could transform the outlook for farmers. ICSA president Patrick Kent said: “It is high time that we turn climate change targets into opportunities for farmers. Instead of the negativity, we could make agriculture part of the solution to climate change targets. However, this requires coherent Government support for national decisions and EU policies which drive renewable energy production from sustainable European farming strategies.”

Mr Kent said that ICSA pushed Minister Naughten to strongly oppose the slashing of the 7% biofuel mandate at the December Council of Ministers meeting in Brussels. ICSA also insisted that the Government should support anaerobic digestion and small scale, roof top solar energy in the Renewable Heat Incentive and Renewable Electricity Support Scheme.

“ICSA has been campaigning against the absurd EU proposals in the Renewable Energy Directive reform which would completely sabotage European farmers who sell over €6 billion worth of crops to biofuel plants in Europe. The loss of this outlet would further undermine EU cereal prices and cause the loss of vital GM free protein animal feeds which are a by-product of biofuel production in Europe. In any event, Ireland needs to have more not less biofuels in the fuel mix if we are to have any hope of meeting climate change targets and in order to avoid even more severe obligations on livestock emissions.”

“ICSA has also been campaigning to make anaerobic digestion a reality in many counties. Apart from the potential to sell energy and to make farms more viable, anaerobic digestion can reduce slurry spreading problems, reduce dependence on fertiliser imports and lower emissions.”

“ICSA also called for roof top solar on farm sheds to get a ring fenced piece of the renewable electricity pie. Some farms have significant electricity consumption patterns but they need to sell surplus to the grid.”

“All of these policies would mark a coherent response to the climate change challenge and more importantly lower the risk of climate change fines for this country. Furthermore, at a time when many farms are struggling for viability due to exploitation in food markets, we must deliver other income possibilities to farmers.”

The ICSA delegation also included general secretary Eddie Punch and rural development chairman Seamus Sherlock. “ICSA was satisfied with the engagement with Minister Naughten particularly with imminent decisions on the renewable heat incentive, further consideration of the renewable electricity support scheme and the crunch phase of the EU biofuel package. We are hopeful that he has been listening to the ICSA view.”




ICSA has laid out a strong case for the extension of hedge cutting and vegetation burning dates in a presentation on the Heritage Bill to the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht. Following the meeting ICSA president Patrick Kent said, “We believe that being able to control vegetation on the hills needs the added flexibility of the month of March and likewise we believe that flexibility around hedge cutting in August is essential.”

On the issue of burning Mr Kent said, “The reality is that burning in the winter months is seldom feasible and that short days and weather patterns means that February rarely works. It must be understood that the land we are talking about is not usually suitable for topping or other types of mechanical control. If we are really interested in wildlife, the best outcome in the long term is achieved by livestock grazing in an extensive manner. It is also important to note that there is a code of practice around controlled burning which ICSA fully advocates.”

On the issue of hedge cutting Mr Kent impressed upon the Committee that, “In practice, farmers are trying to get it all done in three months from September to early December. However, as we have seen this year, a lot of that period is beset with heavy rainfall and poor ground conditions. Moreover neatly trimmed hedges are a critical piece of road safety infrastructure. ICSA believes that roadside hedges in particular should be dealt with in August. If we could at least get the roadside hedge cutting out of the way in August, it makes it more feasible to get the internal hedges done in September and October.

It must also be noted that in GLAS some 7,500 farmers have planted 1,200km of new hedgerows and another 3,300km has been rejuvenated by coppicing and hedge laying. This demonstrates that farmers are keen to maintain diverse landscapes where relatively small fields are divided by hedges. But if we make the maintenance of hedges too challenging by unduly harsh limitations on hedge cutting, then we are creating a perverse disincentive to any more hedgerow planting and a more bland, open countryside fenced only by wire.”

ICSA strongly commended the bill to the Committee insisting we have to be pragmatic about the problems that are impacting severely on farmers and on road users right now.




ICSA is holding a meeting on the looming fodder crisis at the Slieve Russell Hotel, Ballyconnell, Co Cavan on the evening of Tuesday 12 December at 8.00pm. The purpose of the meeting is to explore ways to cope with fodder scarcity and to look at alternatives to too much dependency on hay, silage and straw.

ICSA Cavan chairman Hugh Farrell said, “ICSA has pushed the Department of Agriculture for an urgent fodder transport subsidy. We have to get fodder to where it is needed most as a matter of urgency so the issue of subsidised transport needs to be addressed. We also need to look at ways of supplementing the fodder we do have in order to make it stretch. To this end, ICSA is also calling for a system of meal vouchers to be introduced to help those most affected.”

“I would encourage all local farmers to attend, particularly those who believe the scarcity of fodder may become an issue for them over the coming months. ICSA will be on hand to assist and is actively sourcing fodder supplies to help those most in need.”

Concluding, Mr Farrell said, “ICSA officials will also be addressing the issue of slurry spreading on the night so I would also encourage anybody affected by that issue to attend also.”

Guest speakers on the night will be:

Michael Davey

Beef & Dairy Nutritionist with Specialist Nutrition

Emmet Duffy

AW Ennis – Erin Farm Feeds

Adam Woods

Farmers Journal

Patrick Kent

ICSA National President

All farmers are welcome to attend.

For further information, please contact Hugh Farrell, ICSA Cavan chairman, on 083 4841714 or ICSA office on 057 8662120.



29 NOVEMBER 2017


ICSA president Patrick Kent has welcomed the communication from the Commission on the future CAP saying it represented “an ambitious vision of the role of the Common Agricultural Policy while recognising that fair income for farmers and generational renewal had to be at the heart of it.”

However, Mr Kent said that the communication was under the shadow of uncertainty around the budget for the CAP post 2020. “Unless there is more CAP funding, it is pointless being more ambitious.”

Regarding plans to give member states more flexibility around the design of individual CAP programmes, Mr Kent said that while there were potential attractions to this strategy he would be worried that some member states would go over the top in terms of regulations and implementation in a way that would disadvantage their farmers compared to other member states’ farmers. “ICSA would also be worried that the drafting of individual member state CAP programmes could get bogged down in endless tic-taccing between the Department and Commission, leading to delayed payments and potentially unforeseen penalties afterwards in EU audits.”

“However, on the upside this might be the opportunity to solve previously intractable problems like land eligibility payments on the basis that the EU should not be dictating whether a bit of farm roadway should be eligible or not. Even more significant might be the possibility to devise a better scheme for suckler or sheep farmers but of course, the downside to that might be that France, for example, might outdo us leaving their suckler or sheep farmers way more competitive. This could have unforeseen consequences in terms of who ends up exporting weanlings to Italy or Turkey.”

Mr Kent welcomed the fact that capping payments was on the agenda and expressed the hope that a realistic cap would be in place across Europe with a view to ensuring that large scale operations, including factory controlled or owned feedlots could not continue to get six figure sums from the CAP. “It is unacceptable that farmers get tarnished and the reputation of the CAP undermined because of a tiny minority of cases getting huge payments. Instead, we need to deliver better payments to professional, family sized farms and in this regard, the reference to units in the 5-250 Ha bracket is welcome.”

Mr Kent emphasised that there needs to be greater focus on making sure that all CAP schemes were efficient at delivering money to farmers. “The current RDP scheme is too complex with schemes which leak a lot of funds to advisors and professionals, while delivering small sums to farmers who are meant to be the beneficiaries. This has to change.”

“On generational renewal, we need to recognise that this is a two way process and we should be thinking of a retirement scheme to complement better supports for young farmers.

ICSA also welcomes mention of the bio-economy in the communication.  However, the ability of farmers to produce renewable energy needs to be crystallised in EU and national policies on biofuels, solar energy and anaerobic digestion.”

Mr Kent said that the focus on risk management and income stabilisation tools could not be seen as a substitute for proper incomes. “We are open to persuasion but there is a concern that complex financial instruments could result in leakage of funds out of CAP into the insurance sector. Moreover, there is a worry that income stabilisation could lead to a perverse incentive to cut prices even more by processors/retailers in order to allow the income stabilisation tool to kick in.”

Concluding, Mr Kent said: “The eight key goals for the new CAP is ambitious and this is fine in principle; but we need to have reality in how much we ask farmers to do and we need to ensure that better farm incomes are the most important measure of sustainability. Without better farm incomes, we don’t have generational renewal, we don’t have investment in better technology and we can’t deliver on climate change objectives. Income must be central to any CAP strategy and in this regard, better regulation of the Food Chain involving auditing of margins at processing and retailing level will be essential to ensuring that CAP expenditure is not wasted.”



23 NOVEMBER 2017

ICSA president Patrick Kent has lambasted the EU Commission for selling out the European beef sector in Mercosur talks at the worst possible time due to the uncertainty around markets as a result of Brexit. Speaking following a meeting with the EU chief Mercosur negotiator Sandra Gallina in Brussels yesterday, Mr Kent explained that Brexit put a huge question mark over the 270,000 tons of beef exported to the UK each year.

“It is monumental folly to allow 70,000 tons or more of extra South American beef into the EU at a time when we have no idea what the trading arrangements will be between the UK and Europe. Obviously, the importance of trade with the UK is especially significant to Ireland. However, while it may be Ireland’s problem today, it will be Europe’s problem tomorrow because any interference with free trade between Ireland and the UK could lead to some or all of our current 270,000 tons being displaced onto other EU markets.”

The ICSA president, along with ICSA general secretary Eddie Punch, were in attendance at a briefing for all sectors which are interested in Mercosur including car manufacturers, financial services and food and drink, which was hosted by Ms Gallina. While she accepted that the Irish beef sector was especially sensitive, she admitted that every effort was being made to do a deal.

“It is clear that the EU is willing to sacrifice the EU beef sector in return for potential gains for the car and financial services sector. ICSA is calling on the Taoiseach to make a further very strong intervention with the Commission president Jean Claude Juncker on behalf of the beef sector. We need to have a strong alliance with France against this deal. It is unacceptable that 100,000 livestock farmers in Ireland will pay a disproportionate price.”

ICSA also called into question the coherence of the EU on climate change when this deal will displace local beef with beef imported from thousands of miles away and which is causing destruction of rain forest in South America. “The emissions from transporting beef from the opposite side of the globe and the destruction of forests are ignored in this trade deal. Similarly, the proposals to import ethanol fly in the face of the EU position on reducing crop based ethanol in Europe. Worst of all is the fact that the EU seem to be content to ignore the appalling breaches of food safety standards that occurred in Brazil earlier this year. It is very hard to take the EU seriously when we see such double standards.”



20 NOVEMBER 2017

Irish farming needs balance between the livestock and tillage sectors

ICSA president Patrick Kent has said that the tillage sector in Ireland is in dire straits and ICSA is calling for the tillage forum to be reconvened at the earliest possible date. “A second year of disastrous weather has exposed the frailty of the sector, but there are serious long term issues that need to be looked at urgently.”

“Irish farming needs balance between the livestock and tillage sectors. This is painfully evident at the moment with livestock farmers in the west and border counties crying out for straw and feed. It is not good enough that farmers are openly contemplating having to import straw, silage and hay from outside the island of Ireland. It is not good enough that we have a huge protein deficit in animal feeds not only in Ireland but in Europe.”

“The loss of our sugar beet sector is still a huge problem, and there is a national failure to take this seriously. Meanwhile, the malting sector is being ripped off by the booming drinks industry. Some of the players in the drinks sector like to market their “Irish image” yet the Irish content in the ingredients is minimal. Even where Irish product is used, the price paid does not compensate for the high standards required.”

“Minister Creed needs to put more focus on this critical sector because if it is not dealt with soon, there will be no tillage in the vast majority of the country and this will be a devastating loss not only to the cereals sector but to all livestock farmers as well.”




ICSA president Patrick Kent has described last evening’s meeting with An Taoiseach Leo Varadkar as, “A very useful exchange on the pressing issues currently affecting Irish agriculture including Brexit, Mercosur, CAP funding and climate change.” The meeting was also attended by Michael Creed TD, Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine and Andrew Doyle TD, Minister of State for Food, Forestry & Horticulture and had inputs from ICMSA, IFA and Macra na Feirme.

Mr Kent thanked Mr Varadkar and the Ministers present for the frank exchange and said, “Both short term and longer term strategies are required to navigate the key issues pertaining to the Irish agriculture and food sectors. This requires vision and strong leadership and I look forward to engaging further with the Taoiseach and Ministers Creed and Doyle going forward.”




ICSA Louth chairman Gavin Carberry has said he is outraged at the latest farm related theft to occur in the county. Mr Carberry was referring to the theft of cattle worth €17,000 from the farm of Tom Kirk in Ravanny, Dundalk Co Louth over the weekend. “It’s a disgrace that incidents like this continue to happen and I would encourage anyone with information to contact the Gardaí.”

The theft is believed to have occurred on Saturday evening (4 November) between 6.00pm and 7.00pm when 14 cattle were loaded into a lorry and driven away. A neighbour is believed to have witnessed the lorry being driven suspiciously with no headlights on.

Mr Carberry said “ICSA has undertaken a National Agricultural Crime Survey in conjunction with Waterford Institute of Technology where statistics have shown that two thirds of farmers have experienced crime related to their farming activities. Financially it’s wreaking havoc on farmers, not to mention the stress and emotional impact these crimes have. We all need to work together and be vigilant if we have any hope of seeing that number reduce. We cannot accept crime as part and parcel of life in rural Ireland.”

The cattle in question are described as red Limousins crossed with Charolais and are all approximately 18 months. A reward has been offered for any information leading to their recovery. Relevant information should be passed to Ardee Garda Station on 041 685 3222 or any Garda station.



06 November 2017

ICSA president Patrick Kent has slammed the Citizens’ Assembly proposal to tax farmers for food production emissions as a completely daft idea which is “a lamentable example of group think emerging from a part-time weekend talk shop. When you get daft proposals on additional taxes for farmers enthusiastically backed by 89% of respondents and a proposal for a new quango backed by 98% of respondents, it is obvious that this does not arise from balanced debate and careful reflection.  Instead it suggests that the findings have been orchestrated by the way the debate has been framed and the questions put.”

“Did anyone ponder the hypocrisy of favouring carbon taxes for the end users of fuel but not for beef or dairy?   The reality is that if the Citizens’ Assembly was asked if they favoured food taxes at retail level they would have been a lot slower to jump on the bandwagon.  Moreover, they would then have to reflect on the fact that any such tax would have to be levied not just in Ireland but in every country in the world where we export food.

Applying a tax on Irish food production is daft because it ignores the inconvenient truth that people choose to eat and that most of these people are not actually in Ireland but in markets all over Europe and further afield.  If we close down Irish beef farmers, we simply relocate the production of beef to other parts of the globe where they don’t give a toss about Citizens’ Assemblies.   How stupid would it be to reduce Irish agricultural output so that the likes of Brazil could expand at a far higher environmental cost?

“At least there was some acknowledgement that farming activities also sequester carbon and that farmers should be incentivised for providing carbon sinks.  Contrary to popular belief, this should not be about sitka spruce plantations which are actually very limited in terms of sequestration but about well managed grassland farming combined with the maintenance of biodiverse landscapes.”

“Government and all public representatives need to man up and stop outsourcing policy decisions to hobby weekend policy makers.   It is a wasteful diversionary tactic when we could incentivise farmers to supply solar energy or invest in anaerobic digestion which produces renewable heat while reducing slurry emissions.   Ireland also needs to reject the absurd EU Commission proposals to undermine crop based biofuels on EU farms which produce up to 70% lower GHG emissions than fossil fuels.  While electric vehicles might eventually be attractive as an alternative, we have to deal with today’s fleet today.

“The Government also needs to stand up and be counted on the climate impact of a potential Mercosur trade deal which in essence will result in increased imports of beef and ethanol at significant environmental cost when we could produce all we need of these products in the EU without the global transport emissions involved in imports from South America.”



1 NOV 2O17

ICSA president Patrick Kent has said it is time for common sense to prevail on the issue of tractor NCTs following a meeting with the Department of Transport, Tourism & Sport in Dublin today. “The lack of consultation regarding the introduction of this directive has resulted in ludicrous proposals being presented, such as the unworkable 25km rule. This has resulted in widespread panic amongst farmers who felt they were going to be penalised for simply carrying out their farming activities.”

“A process of engagement with stakeholders has now begun which will hopefully bring a sense of clarity to the situation. ICSA will be pressing the Department to ensure that NCTs will not apply to tractors used for the purposes of farming or agricultural contracting.”